Wine, Whiskey & More
Curated selection. Expert guidance. The perfect bottle for every occasion.
More Than Just a Liquor Store
Curated Selection
Hand-picked wines, whiskeys, and craft beers. No filler — only bottles worth your time.
Expert Staff
Our team knows their stuff. Ask for a recommendation — we'll find your new favorite.
Fair Prices
Quality doesn't have to break the bank. Competitive prices on everything we stock.
Neighborhood Feel
We're not a big box store. We're your neighbors who happen to love great drinks.
Wauwatosa's Newest Destination for Quality Drinks
Opened in summer 2025, Mayfair Spirits Wine & More was built on a simple idea: Wauwatosa deserves a liquor store that feels like home.
We're not here to overwhelm you with endless aisles of mediocre options. We curate. We taste. We stock only what we'd drink ourselves.
Whether you're a whiskey connoisseur hunting for something rare, a wine lover exploring new regions, or just grabbing a six-pack for the game — we've got you covered.
Stop By and Say Hello
We're open 7 days a week, ready to help you find the perfect bottle. No appointment needed — just walk in.